Cost Comparison: Oxygenated Pool Systems vs. Chlorine Pools

As a homeowner with a swimming pool, you want the best for your family. You’ve likely enjoyed many sunny days splashing around but maintaining that crystal-clear water has always been a bit of a hassle. You’ve heard about alternative pool systems, like oxygenated pools, and you’re curious if they might be better than your traditional chlorine setup. At Shasta Pools, we understand your concerns and are here to help you navigate this decision. This article will break down the costs of both oxygenated pool systems and chlorine pools, so you can make an informed choice that suits your needs and budget. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which system might be the best fit for you.

What Are Oxygenated Pools and Chlorine Pools System?

Before diving into the costs, let’s briefly explain the two systems.

Oxygenated Pool Systems
Oxygenated pool systems use ozone and oxygen infused nanobubbles to sanitize the pool water. These systems reduce the need  for traditional chemicals and eliminate the use of chlorine, making the water gentler on your skin and eyes.

Chlorine Pools
Chlorine pools use chlorine-based chemicals to keep the water clean by killing bacteria and algae. Chlorine is a powerful disinfectant but can sometimes cause skin irritation and has a strong odor. These come in the for of liquid, powder or tablets.

What is the Upfront Costs?

Oxygenated Pool Systems:

The initial setup cost for an oxygenated pool system can be higher than for chlorine pools. Here’s a breakdown of the main components and their approximate costs:

• Ozone Generator: $1,500 – $2000
• Oxygen Injector: $1,200 – $2000
• Nanobubble generator: $500 – $3000
• Labor and Plumbing components: $1000 – $2000

So, the total upfront cost for an oxygenated pool system ranges from $4,200 to $9,000.

Chlorine Pools:

Setting up a chlorine pool is generally less expensive initially. Here are the typical costs:

• Chlorinator: $300 – $1250
• Chlorine Chemicals (initial stock): $100 – $200
• Installation: $200 – $500

The total upfront cost for a chlorine pool system range from $600 to $1,500.

Ongoing Maintenance Costs

Oxygenated Pool Systems

While the initial costs are higher, the ongoing maintenance costs for oxygenated pools can be lower:

• Oxygen Supply: $100 – $300 per year
• Routine Maintenance: $50 – $75 per year
• Electricity: $50 – $150 per year

The annual cost for maintaining an oxygenated pool system ranges from $200 to $525.

Chlorine Pools

Chlorine pools typically have higher ongoing costs due to the need for regular chemical purchases:

• Chlorine Chemicals: $300 – $700 per year
• Routine Maintenance: $100 – $200 per year

The annual cost for maintaining a chlorine pool system ranges from $400 to $900.

Long-Term Costs Over 10 Years

To get a clear picture, let’s compare the total costs over a 10-year period.

Oxygenated Pool Systems

• Upfront Cost: $7,500 (average)
• Ongoing Costs: $350 per year
• Total Over 10 Years: $11,000

Chlorine Pools

• Upfront Cost: $1,050 (average)
• Ongoing Costs: $650 per year
• Total Over 10 Years: $7,550

While oxygenated pool systems are slightly more expensive over the decade, the difference isn’t massive. However, there are other factors to consider beyond just the costs.

Health and Safety Considerations

Oxygenated Pool Systems

• Pros: Gentler on the skin and eyes, no strong chlorine odor, fewer chemicals, with some anecdotal medical benefits of introducing oxygen into its swimmers’ bodies; effective at killing bacteria and viruses.
• Cons: Higher upfront costs.

Chlorine Pools

• Pros: Lower upfront costs, effective at killing bacteria.
• Cons: Can cause skin and eye irritation, strong smell, higher ongoing chemical costs and potential negative, long term health challenges

Environmental Impact

Oxygenated Pool Systems	Oxygenated systems are more eco-friendly since they use fewer chemicals. This reduces the amount of harmful substances that can enter the environment, making them a greener choice.
Chlorine Pools	Chlorine pools can contribute to environmental pollution due to the regular addition of chemicals. This can have a negative impact on local water systems and wildlife.

Ease of Use and Maintenance

Oxygenated Pool Systems	Oxygenated systems generally require less frequent maintenance and fewer chemical adjustments. However, the technology might be more complex, necessitating occasional professional servicing.
Chlorine Pools	Chlorine pools require regular monitoring and chemical balancing. While this can be done by the homeowner, it can be time-consuming and requires a good understanding of pool chemistry.

Longevity of Equipment

Oxygenated Pool Systems	Oxygenated systems can have a longer lifespan compared to chlorine systems. For example, ozone generators and oxygen compressors can last up to 10 years with proper maintenance.
Chlorine Pools	Chlorine systems may require more frequent replacements of parts like chlorinators, salt chlorinators and pumps, which can add to the long-term costs.

Making the Decision: Which Is Right for You?

Deciding between an oxygenated pool system and a chlorine pool depends on your specific needs and priorities.

Budget: If your primary concern is the initial cost, a chlorine pool might be more appealing due to its lower setup costs. However, if you’re thinking long-term, an oxygenated system might offer better value over time.

Health Concern: If you or your family members have sensitive skin or allergies, the gentler water of an oxygenated pool system, with its anecdotal health benefit potential, could be a significant advantage.

Environmental Impact: For eco-conscious homeowners, an oxygenated pool system is the better choice due to its lower chemical usage.

Maintenance Preferences: If you prefer a low-maintenance option, an oxygenated pool system might be the way to go, even though it requires a higher upfront investment.

In conclusion, both oxygenated pool systems and chlorine pools have their pros and cons. The choice ultimately depends on your budget, health considerations, environmental concerns, and maintenance preferences. At Shasta Pools, we’re here to help you make the best decision for your family and your home. Whether you choose an oxygenated pool system or stick with a traditional chlorine pool, our team is ready to support you with expert advice and top-notch service.

If you’re interested in exploring more about pool maintenance options, check out The Best Sanitation System For Arizona Pools. Or, if you’re ready to discuss upgrading your pool system, contact us today for a consultation.

By understanding the costs and benefits, you can make a well-informed decision that keeps your pool clean, safe, and enjoyable for years to come.